Skip to main content

AV Preeminent® • Florida Bar #867470 (36 Years Licensed)

Verified Reported Decisions

Published Case Law & Litigation Track Record

Every entry below reflects a verifiable judicial record across the Supreme Court of Florida, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida, Florida’s Third and Fourth District Courts of Appeal, and South Florida Circuit Courts—paired with a plain-English explanation of why each ruling mattered.

Federal Appellate & District Commercial & Real Estate Development
2001 • U.S. District Court, Southern District of Florida & U.S. Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals

Argonaut Development Group, Inc. v. SWH Funding Corp.

Citation: 150 F. Supp. 2d 1357 (S.D. Fla. 2001), aff’d, 45 Fed. Appx. 884 (11th Cir. 2002)

Legal Issue & Holding

Issue: Whether a real estate developer could hold a commercial lender liable for breach of a joint-venture letter, breach of fiduciary duty, fraud, and promissory estoppel when express conditions precedent in the venture letter were never satisfied.

Disposition: Summary judgment granted across all counts for the defense and affirmed by the Eleventh Circuit. Held that unfulfilled conditions precedent prevented a binding joint venture from maturing, arm’s-length commercial counterparties do not unilaterally owe fiduciary duties, and fraud claims cannot duplicate breach-of-contract damages.

Why This Case Mattered (Plain English)

Frequently cited by Florida state and federal courts over the past two decades, this decision protects commercial lenders and investors from being dragged into multi-million-dollar "handshake partnership" lawsuits when preliminary deal letters clearly require pre-conditions before a deal becomes binding.

Florida Supreme & Appellate Appellate & Choice-of-Law Litigation
1999 • Supreme Court of Florida

Fulton County Administrator v. Sullivan

Citation: 753 So. 2d 549 (Fla. 1999)

Legal Issue & Holding

Issue: High-profile certified-question appeal before the Supreme Court of Florida examining interstate choice-of-law rules (significant-relationships test) and whether fraudulent concealment tolls statutes of limitations.

Disposition: Upon rehearing before the Supreme Court of Florida, the Court withdrew its prior opinion, determined under Florida choice-of-law principles that Georgia’s statute of limitations governed the underlying action rather than Florida’s statute, and declined to reach the certified Florida tolling question.

Why This Case Mattered (Plain English)

Demonstrates appellate advocacy at the highest level of the Florida judiciary on complex procedural questions—specifically which state’s time limits control when a dispute crosses state lines.

Florida Supreme & Appellate Civil Trial & Appellate Standards
1998 • Florida Fourth District Court of Appeal

Tarleton v. Arnstein & Lehr

Citation: 719 So. 2d 325 (Fla. 4th DCA 1998)

Legal Issue & Holding

Issue: Appellate review of the evidentiary and proximate-cause ("case-within-a-case") burden required to sustain or overturn a jury verdict in professional liability litigation.

Disposition: Articulated the controlling three-prong Florida standard for proving professional negligence and proximate causation—establishing when trial evidence suffices for a jury to determine what the underlying outcome would have been absent error.

Why This Case Mattered (Plain English)

Became a foundational Fourth DCA precedent cited hundreds of times across Florida courts on how proximate cause and trial-level damages must actually be proven rather than assumed.

Federal Appellate & District Federal Litigation & Rule 11 Defense
2019 • U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit

Rocket Real Estate, LLC, et al. v. Maestres

Citation: Case No. 17-12826 (11th Cir. Jan. 30, 2019)

Legal Issue & Holding

Issue: Appeal challenging the Southern District of Florida’s denial of an opposing litigant’s motion for Rule 11 and inherent-power sanctions alleging bad-faith litigation and fraud on the court.

Disposition: The Eleventh Circuit affirmed denial of sanctions in full on both procedural and substantive grounds: the movant violated Rule 11(c)(2)’s mandatory 21-day safe-harbor requirement, and the record confirmed zero sanctionable misconduct or fraud on the court by appellees or counsel.

Why This Case Mattered (Plain English)

Confirmed both strict federal procedural guardrails (the 21-day safe-harbor rule) and complete substantive vindication when contentious adversaries attempt to weaponize sanctions motions in federal court.

Federal Appellate & District Federal Appellate Practice
1998 • U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit

Gattis v. Brice

Citation: 136 F.3d 724 (11th Cir. 1998)

Legal Issue & Holding

Issue: Published Eleventh Circuit appeal addressing evidentiary proof required to impose liability on a governmental entity based on alleged ratification by final policymakers.

Disposition: Affirmed summary judgment, holding that liability requires concrete proof that a final policymaker knew of and ratified improper motives—not mere approval of an administrative recommendation.

Why This Case Mattered (Plain English)

Reinforced rigorous federal summary-judgment evidentiary standards in the Eleventh Circuit: speculation does not get a case to a jury without hard record proof.

Florida Supreme & Appellate South Florida Appellate Litigation
2001 • Florida Third District Court of Appeal

City of Miami Beach v. Mendelson

Citation: 798 So. 2d 760 (Fla. 3d DCA 2001)

Legal Issue & Holding

Issue: Appellate review before the Third District Court of Appeal arising out of Miami-Dade municipal civil litigation.

Disposition: Reported Third District Court of Appeal disposition resolving municipal appellate claims in South Florida.

Why This Case Mattered (Plain English)

Reflects multi-decade appellate continuity across both of South Florida’s primary appellate courts—the Third DCA (Miami-Dade/Monroe) and Fourth DCA (Broward/Palm Beach).

Complex Circuit Litigation Condominium Deposit & Fraud Disputes
2010 • Circuit Court of the 17th Judicial Circuit, Broward County, Florida

Fort Lauderdale Oceanfront Condo-Hotel Preconstruction Deposit Litigation (SB Hotel Associates / Developer Group)

Citation: Broward County Circuit Court (17th Judicial Circuit, 2010–2011)

Legal Issue & Holding

Issue: Multi-plaintiff preconstruction deposit recovery action on behalf of 41 condominium-hotel buyers seeking return of more than $6 million in escrow deposits under Florida Statutes Ch. 718, FDUTPA, and misrepresentation theories after project collapse.

Disposition: Defeated developers’ and licensors’ early motions to dismiss before the Broward Circuit Court, allowing purchasers’ statutory and misrepresentation claims over developer branding vs. licensing representations to proceed into merits litigation.

Why This Case Mattered (Plain English)

Illustrates coordinated, high-stakes South Florida buyer representation when preconstruction luxury developments stall, alter terms, or blur who actually stands behind the project.

Note per Florida Bar Rules: Prospective clients may not obtain the same or similar results. Every case turns on its own governing contracts, admissible facts, and controlling law.