Skip to main content

AV Preeminent® • Florida Bar #867470 (36 Years Licensed)

Q&A Knowledge Base

Direct Answers on Florida Litigation, Real Estate & Case Selection

Clear, plain-English explanations of Florida statutes, trial timelines, condominium escrow rules, commercial lease protections, and how our firm evaluates prospective engagements.

Case Selection, Ethics & Firm Philosophy

How Joseph E. Altschul, LLC evaluates prospective matters, screens conflicts, and maintains candid client alignment.

What does "We do not take every case—we take the right ones and fight them properly" mean in practice?

Before accepting any litigation engagement, Mr. Altschul personally reviews the governing contracts, timeline, damages math, and collectability. By declining speculative or over-leveraged files, the firm devotes direct, partner-level trial preparation to every client we represent—never handing critical depositions or hearings off to inexperienced junior associates.

What is a Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent® rating?

AV Preeminent® is the highest peer-review rating awarded by Martindale-Hubbell based on confidential evaluations by fellow attorneys and members of the judiciary. It signifies that a lawyer’s peers rank him at the highest standard of both legal ability and ethical integrity.

Why must I disclose the opposing party’s name before sending confidential documents?

Under the Rules Regulating The Florida Bar, an attorney must run a conflict-of-interest check against current and former clients—including affiliated title closings—before reviewing sensitive adverse strategy materials. Providing all party names upfront protects both you and existing clients.

Does submitting the online Case Review form create an attorney-client relationship?

No. Submitting information through this website requests a preliminary conflict check and merits evaluation only. An attorney-client relationship with Joseph E. Altschul, LLC is formed exclusively through a mutually signed written engagement agreement.

Which courts in Florida and federal jurisdictions is Joseph E. Altschul admitted to?

Joseph E. Altschul (Florida Bar #867470, admitted October 22, 1990) is admitted to all Florida Circuit Courts, District Courts of Appeal, and the Supreme Court of Florida, as well as the U.S. District Courts for the Southern and Middle Districts of Florida, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, and the Supreme Court of the United States.

Commercial Litigation & Business Trial Strategy

Practical timelines, fee-shifting rules, and trial readiness in South Florida business disputes.

How long does a commercial lawsuit take in Broward, Miami-Dade, or Palm Beach County?

Under Florida’s differentiated case management rules, streamlined civil cases typically target trial readiness within 12 months, general commercial cases within 18 months, and complex multi-party disputes within 24 months—though targeted summary judgment motions or injunctive hearings can resolve key issues much earlier.

Can the winning party recover attorney’s fees in a Florida business lawsuit?

Under the "American Rule" followed in Florida, each side pays its own attorney’s fees unless a specific contract clause or Florida statute (such as FDUTPA § 501.2105, non-compete enforcement § 542.335(1)(k), or Proposals for Settlement under § 768.79) authorizes prevailing-party fee recovery.

What remedies exist when a 50/50 LLC partner locks me out of company accounts or books?

Under Florida’s Revised LLC Act (Chapter 605), an excluded member may demand statutory financial inspection under § 605.0410, seek emergency injunctive or receivership relief to prevent asset dissipation, pursue direct or derivative claims for breach of fiduciary duty of loyalty and care, or petition for judicial dissolution and buyout.

When should appellate counsel get involved in a high-stakes trial?

Before verdict—not after. Many Florida appeals are won or lost on whether specific evidentiary objections, jury instructions, verdict forms, and motions for directed verdict were properly preserved on the trial record.

What is the statute of limitations for breach of a written contract in Florida?

Under Florida Statutes § 95.11(2)(b), an action on a written contract generally carries a five-year statute of limitations (four years for oral contracts under § 95.11(3)(j), and one year for certain statutory or specific-performance claims). Contractual notice-and-cure windows can require action within days, so prompt review is essential.

Preconstruction Condo Deposits & Real Estate Fraud

Statutory buyer protections under Chapter 718, Chapter 720, ILSFDA, and Florida non-disclosure law.

When can a buyer legally recover a preconstruction condominium deposit in Florida?

Primary legal grounds include: (1) exercising the initial 15-day statutory cooling-off period after receiving full Chapter 718 offering documents; (2) exercising a fresh 15-day cancellation window under § 718.503 after receiving a developer amendment that materially and adversely alters the offering; (3) developer breach of an unconditional outside completion deadline; (4) misleading promotional materials actionable under § 718.506 or FDUTPA; or (5) federal ILSFDA disclosure violations.

If a condo developer raises monthly HOA/condo fees before closing, can I cancel and get my deposit back?

Substantial increases in projected condominium budget assessments—beyond uncontrollable statutory pass-throughs like insurance or taxes—frequently trigger the 15-day "material and adverse" rescission right under § 718.503, Fla. Stat., provided written cancellation notice is strictly and timely served.

Can a residential home seller hide roof leaks, mold, or unpermitted additions behind an "As-Is" contract?

No. Under the Florida Supreme Court’s landmark rule in Johnson v. Davis, 480 So. 2d 625 (Fla. 1985), residential sellers must disclose known facts materially affecting the value of the property that are not readily observable by the buyer—even when using a standard FAR/BAR "As-Is" contract.

Does the "As-Is" caveat emptor rule apply differently to commercial real estate in Florida?

Yes. Florida applies caveat emptor ("buyer beware") to commercial property sales, meaning passive non-disclosure alone rarely supports a claim. However, active fraudulent misrepresentation, intentional concealment preventing inspection, or breach of express contractual warranties remains fully actionable in commercial deals.

How may a Florida developer legally use my preconstruction deposit above 10% of the purchase price?

Under Florida Statutes § 718.202, deposits up to 10% must remain in strict escrow (unless properly bonded under statutory alternatives), while deposits exceeding 10% may be used only for actual construction and development of the condominium property once construction has commenced and statutory contract legends are strictly met.

Real Estate Closings, Title & Commercial Leases

Title insurance, municipal liens, commercial lease guaranties, and foreclosure deficiency protections.

How does Joseph E. Altschul, LLC work with Trinity Title & Escrow, LLC?

Many residential and commercial closings handled by the firm are coordinated alongside our affiliated title agency, Trinity Title & Escrow, LLC (trinitytitle.us). Clients receive seamless title examination, escrow handling, and title insurance issuance paired with experienced real estate legal counsel when contract or title issues arise.

Does standard owner’s title insurance cover unrecorded city code violations or open permits?

No. A standard title search checks recorded public deeds, mortgages, and judgments, whereas open building permits, unrecorded code enforcement fines, and unpaid utility balances require a separate municipal lien search—critical in Broward, Miami-Dade, and Palm Beach Counties.

How can a business owner limit personal liability when signing a commercial lease?

Strategies include negotiating a "good-guy guaranty" (ending personal liability upon lawful surrender and rent payment through move-out), a rolling dollar cap or time burn-off after 24–36 months of timely rent payments, or substituting an increased security deposit / letter of credit.

What documents must I verify before completing a short sale or deed in lieu of foreclosure?

Never sign closing documents assuming the remaining loan balance disappears. An attorney must confirm explicit, unambiguous written language from every lienholder cancelling the remaining debt and waiving all deficiency claims—and advise you on evaluating potential IRS cancellation-of-debt tax reporting (Form 1099-C / Form 982).

How long does a mortgage lender have to sue for a deficiency judgment in Florida?

Under Florida Statutes § 95.11(5)(h), an action to enforce a deficiency judgment following foreclosure of a residential one-to-four-family dwelling must be commenced within strictly one year after the day following issuance of the clerk’s certificate of title.

Legal Fees, Billing Philosophy & Engagement Process

Transparent fee structures designed around value, competence, and cost-effective resolution.

How does Joseph E. Altschul, LLC structure legal fees?

We do not aspire to be the cheapest firm in South Florida, nor the most expensive. Depending on the matter, engagements are structured via transparent hourly retainers, flat/fixed transactional fees for defined contract or closing scopes, or hybrid hourly-plus-contingency structures in qualifying high-merit recovery actions—always documented clearly in writing upfront.

Will my case be handed off to junior associates after I sign a retainer?

No. Clients hire Joseph E. Altschul for 36 years of courtroom and real estate judgment—and receive direct partner representation on strategy, drafting, negotiations, depositions, and trial.

What documents should I gather before requesting a Case Review?

Gather the fully signed contract (plus all addenda or amendments), any default or demand notices received, escrow deposit receipts, key email/text timelines, and the exact legal names of all opposing individuals and entities so conflict screening and deadline triage can happen immediately.

Do you work as Florida local counsel or trial co-counsel for out-of-state law firms?

Yes. Given Mr. Altschul’s admissions in the Southern and Middle Districts of Florida, the Eleventh Circuit, and all Florida courts, the firm selectively serves as South Florida trial or local counsel for out-of-state corporate counsel and litigation boutiques.

How quickly will the firm respond to time-sensitive statutory deadlines (like a 15-day condo rescission window or 20-day summons)?

When submitting via the Case Review portal, select the Urgent Statutory/Court Deadline flag and state the exact response date. Matters facing imminent 15-day Chapter 718 rescission windows, TRO hearings, or 20-day complaint response deadlines are prioritized for immediate conflict and calendar review.